Matthew Weaver (NamUs #MP51786) - Case Details

By: Shane Lambert


Missing person Matthew Weaver
I spoke online tonight with an individual (Matthew's ex-girlfriend) who was in charge of the Facebook group called "Help Find Matthew Weaver Jr." (October 7th, 2018). As a result of this online conversation, I wanted to add some details to his missing-person's case that might help the websleuths out there. Firstly, here are the details from NamUs where Matthew Weaver is #MP51786.

  • His date of last contact was August 10th, 2018
  • He is missing from Topanga, California
  • He was 21 years old the day he went missing
  • White male
  • 5'10" and 130 pounds
  • Brown hair and hazel eyes
  • Partial beard and mustache
  • He was wearing a Los Angeles Angels baseball cap, red shoes, and Dickies pants; the likeness of the cap, according to the Facebook group's admin, is pictured below  
  • NamUs says that his car was found abandoned near Rosa's Overlook on the Topanga Lookout Trail.


Regarding the circumstances, in the area where Matthew's car was found, there was a 911 phone call that might be linked to Matthew (this is not clear). Hikers reported hearing a man and a woman call for help according to an NBC article I read. Whether the said man was Matthew is not clear. According to the NBC article: "just after midnight on August 11 in the area near where surveillance footage last captured Matthew’s car, hikers called police to report hearing a male and female calling for help" (NBC).

I asked the individual who runs the Facebook group whether Matthew might have been with this said woman. The answer was that the "911 call cries of help yielded no results in locating Matthew Weaver or anyone else that needed assistance." This call could be a red herring but it is hard to ignore as well because of the proximity to Matthew's car and because of how close it was to his last-seen time.

I asked the Facebook group admin several more questions and they are answered below.

(1) Does Matthew have any tattoos?

Answer: "He has Jeremiah tattooed over his chest."

(2) Does he have any piercings?

Answer: "He has his ears pierced."

(3) Did he have any markings like a birthmark or scar?

Answer: "No."

(4) Was there anything unique about him due to a surgery or a medical procedure in the past?

Answer: "No."

(5) Was he an avid user of the trails?

Answer: "he was not a hiker but he knew the canyon roads well because he enjoyed driving on them."

Subjective Commentary:

If you come across an unidentified person's report with a described tattoo of "Jeremiah" prominent on the UPs chest, then think of Matthew and be aware that this tattoo was not in his NamUs profile at the time of writing. Hence, someone in the future might not match a UP to Matthew based on this tattoo. It would, therefore, be smart to do a periodic manual search of such a tattoo among UPs. I did such a search on October 7th, 2018 and found no hits.

Matthew's stated lack of familiarity with the trails could be a major clue. It might suggest that he got lost if he did, in fact, decide to venture on the trail network as his absence from his vehicle suggests.

But when I read about Matthew's case, I found the timeline enigmatic. He seemed active late in the evening on Thursday, August 9th and it seemed like he partied until the early hours of the morning  of August 10th when he left the company of a woman at 4:30am. He also posted a SnapChat video at 5:30am or 6am, which starts to call into question when exactly he fell asleep. His car was seen on surveillance at 7:12am and there appears to be contact from him at 11:30am, which further calls into question when he slept. If the after-midnight (ie. early August 11th) 911 call pertains to Matthew it seems like he would have been away from a bed for more than 24 hours.

Lastly, there is the question of the hikers and their claim to hear a "male and female" call for help just after midnight on August 11th. I've wondered if that should have been a "male OR female" but the NBC article said "male AND female." If that was, in fact, Matthew and an unknown woman calling for help then there could be a missing woman here too. If you ever come across a report of a missing woman with the exact same last-seen date as Michael (or a day very close to it - August 10th, 2018) the consider whether this missing person might be related to Matthew's missing person's case. At time of writing, there was no such report in NamUs but one might yet get posted.

Carmen Robinson vs. Jesokah Adkens: BC’s Unsolved Mysteries Involving Missing Teens

By: Shane Lambert
Original: October 2018
Updated: February 4th, 2021 and February 4th, 2025




I researched the disappearance of Carmen Robinson tonight for a little while. I thought that I would do a bullet-point style summary of what I learned about her case from reading about her in online-newspaper databases. First, here are her important case details as per DoeNetwork:

  • Missing since December 8th, 1973 (a Saturday) from Victoria, BC, Canada (on Vancouver Island)
  • 17 years old at the time of her disappearance
  • White female with long blonde hair
  • The night she went missing she worked at the Ingraham Hotel as a dishwasher, boarded a bus home, got off the bus at West Burnside Road and Holland Avenue, and has not been seen since then (her home was two blocks away)

Details I got from news coverage

  • Known child-killer Clifford Olson is mentioned in conjunction with the disappearance; it is stated in an article that he was flown to Surrey "to provide clues on the 1973 murder of teenager Carmen Robinson"; Allan Williams, BC Attorney General at the time, said he was "satisfied it was not a waste of time" (December 4th, 1982; Page 3 of the Ottawa Citizen)
  • A later article about Olson indicates that he was lying about any involvement in the disappearance of Robinson (Jan 3, 1983 Ottawa Citizen, Page 2)
  • The only lead they had in the case was from a woman who claimed to have seen Carmen arguing with a man two nights before her disappearance but this lead involved placing the witness under hypnosis
  • "The witness described a man with a swarthy complexion, black hair and a full beard. She said Robinson got into his car, an early '70s Chevy Nova or Plymouth Duster painted burnt orange."
  • "The car had a bumper sticker with the name Ferguson. With help from the public, police matched the sticker to a school board election in B.C.'s interior. It still remains one of only leads in the case." (Time Colonist, online, September 23rd, 2008)

February 4th, 2025 Update: Similar Case in the Region

I felt that there was a chance that the case could be related to the 2021 disappearance of Jesokah Adkens. She went missing in the same part of Vancouver Island (ie. about half an hour away) and the cases do resemble one another in other ways.

Firstly, the missing people resemble each other in terms of hair color, hairstyle, age, sex, and race. Secondly, they both were last seen at a bus stop. Lastly, they both went missing at the same time of night.

Also, at the time of her disappearance,  I think Carmen was in an area that was fairly rural. I would think this would be not quite so true for Jesokah, but she did live in a smaller community. Both disappeared fairly close to home.

February 4th, 2021 Update: Women Missing During Commute

There hasn't been a major update in this case that I know of since I originally published this article. Carmen's disappearance was recapped in December 2020 with various British Columbian news sources. The update I will provide here has to do with just some new thoughts I've had on the case.

Since 2018, I've profiled at least two cases that are similar to Carmen's. These similarities are in no way meant to mean the cases are related in an investigative way. Rather, I can think of two cases of missing women that went missing during their work shifts or commutes. 

Jessica Heeringa is an individual who went missing toward the end of a shift she worked at a convenience store. Kierra Coles is someone who went missing in his United States Postal Clerk uniform. My thoughts on a worker who goes missing during a work shift or during a commute is that the person who disappeared her knew her patterns well. However, a chance encounter with a stranger can't be discounted.


NamUs #MP11495 - Donella Jean Coultas

By: Shane Lambert

Donella Jean Coultas was last seen on December 18th, 1979. NamUs offers some details of her description but nothing for circumstances.


  • 29 years old at the time of the disappearance
  • White female
  • 5'7"
  • 157 lbs
  • Alias: Donna Schuman
  • Last known location: South Pasadena
  • Brown hair, short
  • Blue eyes
  • Contact lenses
  • Pidgeon toed
  • C-section scar on abdomen
  • Mole above navel
  • Buck teeth
  • She was last known to be wearing a green top under a light-blue sweater and dark-blue pants with white tennis shoes
I did not find much media coverage regarding Donella Jean Coultas. But I did find one article 11 months after her disappearance in The Desert Sun, a publication out of Palm Springs. Donna's mother was named "Mrs. Schuman" in the article which suggests the alias above is a maiden name. Donna's mother stated that she thought it was possible that Donna went to Palm Springs. But the big mystery with this missing person is why she would leave a 2-year old behind.


For those wondering about some circumstances with this case, the above blurb is all I found for you.

Kassandra Ramirez (NamUs #MP52542) - New to NamUs














Kassandra Ramirez is a missing person that is new to NamUs. She was last seen on September 19th, 2018 in the Bronx, New York at 683 Melrose Avenue at around 11:40pm. Her vitals as of the 19th were as follows:
  • 25 years old
  • Hispanic/Latino female
  • 5'2" to 5'3"
  • 100 to 130 pounds
  • Brown hair
  • Brown eyes
She was leaving her residence to meet with someone in front of her building. That individual says that Ramirez did not show up. She was last seen wearing the following:
  • Blue jeans
  • White blouse
  • Grey hoodie
  • Black sneakers
Facebook questions with Kassandra's mother

Kassandra's mother offered some information that wasn't on NamUs at time of writing. She said her daughter's middle name is Briana. Furthermore, Kassandra has tattoos and a birthmark (still trying to find locations of them). Additionally, she had a c-section and she has scars on her left pinky due to an injury.


I spoke with other people that knew Kassandra well and were involved in efforts to locate her. Tattoos may have the following: a Pisces symbol, the name "Jay'Den," and the dates "11/16/10 - 11/18/10." One tattoo may be on her wrist of the name and dates. She may also have a birthmark on her abdomen. 

Food For Thought: Similar disappearance

Kassandra Ramirez disappeared about one year to the hour after Corinna Slusser disappeared. Ramirez disappeared very close to midnight on September 19th, 2018 and Slusser disappeared in the wee hours of the morning on September 20th, 2017. Their last known locations are about 10 miles apart. They were both mid-week disappearances. Slusser's case has been associated with sex-trafficking rings.

NamUs #UP6040 - Notes for Websleuths

By: Shane Lambert

I was looking at NamUs #UP6040 today. She is an individual that was found dead on February 19th, 1971 in Lake Panasoffkee, Florida. Her NamUs vitals:


  • Aged 17-24
  • White female
  • Estimated to have died in 1971 within weeks of her discovery
  • 5'3"
  • 110 pounds
  • Brown hair
  • Eyes are probably brown


She was found under the Lake Panasoffkee Bridge at Interstate 75.

NamUs mentioned her clothing, which included green plaid pants and a poncho. Some details that websleuths should be aware of that you don't get from NamUs comes from the newspaper reporting of the day (Orlando Sentinel/Feb 21 1971/Page 66 unless otherwise noted):
  • This woman was definitely thought to be a murder victim who was strangled with a belt (one article from Feb 22 1971 said she was found "with a belt tied around her neck" Sentinel Page 5)
  • She may have been pregnant
  • She was referred to as the "hippie-type"
  • She was believed to have been thrown over the side of the bridge
  • She had a gold cap on a tooth
  • The body was found by two young men hitchhikers who looked down from the bridge
  • She was barefoot (Feb 22 Sentinel)
  • She was dressed in "a Kelly green, long-sleeved blouse and green and cream plaid slacks" (Feb 22 Sentinel)
  • Her location is described as between "Wildwood and Bushnell" (Tampa Tribune/Feb 27 1971)
  • They were able to get a fingerprint
  • They have her dentals

Commentary

When you are reading missing-person reports, the clothing is big in this case. But try to remember that she had a gold cap on a tooth. If you ever read of a report of a woman who was last heard from in February 1971 or prior with a gold cap on her tooth then cross reference her details against NamUs #UP6040 to see if anything lines up.

NamUs #MP8602 - Notes on Ashley Fuller Reed

By: Shane Lambert

The Original Time of Writing
: October 1st, 2018
Updates: February 25th, 2025

On October 1st, 2018 I took a look at the missing person's case of Ashley Fuller Reed (NamUs #MP8602). I read over her case at NamUs and then used an online-newspaper database to look at the reporting from 1990 that covered her case. I feel that anyone websleuthing this case should know about details that I came across during this research. It's my opinion that NamUs doesn't provide enough information.

Furthermore, I took a look at the greater region and the large time frame associated with this case. I've noted numerous cases of white females going missing from Texas after experiencing car troubles between 1988 and 1994. These cases may or may not be related.


NamUs says that Reed was last heard from on January 15th, 1990, a Monday holiday (Martin Luther King Jr. Day). One newspaper article (El Paso Times/March 24th, 1990/page 13) contradicted that and said that she vanished on January 14th, which would have been a Sunday.

My guess from that is that she disappeared late on the 14th or early on the 15th. Since we're dealing with a Sunday night followed by a holiday Monday then certainly going out late wouldn't be unexpected from someone Reed's age.

Her vitals as per NamUs:
  • 19 years old when she disappeared
  • White female
  • 5'2" to 5'3"
  • 115 to 125 pounds
  • Brown and curly hair
  • Brown eyes
  • Pierced ears
  • Small brown mole on lower-left cheek
  • Wearing a stone-washed blue denim shirt, a black long-sleeved top, a brown bomber jacket, a Guess brand watch, two gold rings, and gold hoop earrings.

She was last known to be in Garland, Texas. The night she was last heard from, according to NamUs, she was going to The International House of Pancakes with two unidentified men. Her car was then found on a freeway ramp leading to her neighbourhood. That is a factor that suggests that she was abducted from her vehicle or that someone abducted her elsewhere and chose to place her vehicle there.

Personally, what I can't ignore is that the vehicle was found en route to her home. To me, that suggests that she drove it there and was abducted from it. If someone abducted her beforehand then I don't think that person would drive toward her home in her vehicle because that would be a risky move.

It may be difficult to picture how someone could be abducted from a vehicle, especially one that is moving. However, on the matter of women being abducted from vehicles, please consider my article called "Women With Car Troubles Go Missing" from February 14th, 2018. The article shows, with reference to historical cases, how an abductor is able to sabotage a woman's vehicle, follow her, and then gain her trust as a Johnny-on-the-spot mechanic that can help her. What should be noted is that it's possible to convince someone to pull over even when no car trouble exists for that person.

In regard to the men that Reed was meeting at the pancake house, websleuths should be aware of the name "Robert." The following clip is taken from the El Paso Times (March 24th, 1990; page 13).


Furthermore, Reed's case was mentioned in a September 6th, 1992 article in The Post-Crescent (page 2), a newspaper in Appleton, Wisconsin. This article mentions that the other male's name that Ashley Fuller Reed was going to meet was "Dave." This article says that Reed, "Dave," and "Robert" were going to meet in Dallas International House of Pancakes at 6pm on Jan. 14th, 1990.

One detail that websleuths should be aware of from this article is that her car was found with a dead battery. Furthermore, the article says that when the battery was recharged, the hazard lights came on. Her purse and keys were missing from the car.

Ashley Fuller Reed made the news in recent times, as of February 25th, 2025. The Irving Journal reviewed her case in January 2025.
  • Her car was a 1984 Chevrolet Citation.
  • It was discovered on January 15th on the service road of Interstate 635 at Military Parkway in Mesquite.
  • Two weeks after she disappeared, two fishermen found her purse at a gravel pit, however, somehow this purse "vanished" before police could look at it.

Subjective opinion - My Guess

My guess is that Reed left the International House of Pancakes on her own and started to drive home. While doing this, she either perceived car troubles or someone falsely alerted her to contrived troubles with the vehicle. Reacting to this, maybe she put her hazards on and pulled over. Then, she could have met with a 'Good Samaritan' who was a wolf in sheep's clothes.

Perhaps Reed turned the ignition off in her car with the hazard light button still depressed, perhaps believing that she would get help and return to the car soon. The person who offered to help her may have instead abducted her. Meanwhile, the hazard lights would have flickered all night until they killed the battery. With the hazard-light button still depressed, when the battery was recharged the lights lit up.

Similar case(s) involving Texas White Females with Abandoned cars around 1990

These cases are not necessarily connected. However, I feel that they are good "food for thought."

1988 Susan Renee Smalley and Stacie Madison


Susan Renee Smalley (NamUs #MP989) went missing in 1988 along with Stacie Madison (#MP1487) in Carrollton, Texas. They were white females aged 18 and 17 respectively. Madison's car was found abandoned. The excerpt below is from the May 8th, 1988 Odessa American newspaper (page 13).



1991 Kristen Smith


The case of Kristen Smith (NamUs #MP8669) involves the disappearance of a white female in 1991 who was a similar age to Ashley Reed. Smith went missing from Beaumont, Texas. A significant point of similarity is that Smith's car was also found abandoned.

1992 Kelly Dae Wilson


Kelly Dae Wilson (NamUs #MP6816) went missing from Gilmer, Texas in January of 1992. Wilson is a white female who was 17 at the time of her disappearance. Her car was found abandoned (with a flat tire which police believe was slashed) as well and her keys were missing.

1992 Tara Suzette Breckenridge


Tara Breckenridge

Tara Suzette Breckenridge (NamUs #MP914) went missing in August of 1992 from Houston, Texas. She was a white female, aged 23 years old. Her abandoned car was also found. I did find an individual named "Robert" associated with this case as a suspect but he would have been 15 at the time of Reed's disappearance (Del Rio News Herald/April 1st 1993/Page 1).

Please read the excerpt below, which was taken from the Del Rio News Herald (page 1) on August 15th, 1992.


The vehicle's alternator belt was missing according to NamUs. If it was broken down, then that would be one matter but the alternator belt to be missing means vehicle sabotage to me. That could mean that Tara excepted help from the Johnny-on-the-spot 'Good Samaritan' voluntarily, believing that he would help her.

1994 Jeanie Naomi Lofton


Jeanie Naomi Lofton (NamUs #MP8600) went missing in April of 1994 from Carthage, Texas (note: a newspaper article written in April 2002 called her "Jeanie Voiselle Lofton"). She was a 21-year old white female. The following excerpt is taken from the May 25th, 1994 article on Lofton in the Longview News-Journal. It states that her car was found abandoned.


In this case, Lofton left her home to run errands on April 2nd, 1994. One of her errands was to go to the Eckerd Drug Store in Carthage to get a prescription for her son's illness. She did complete this errand as his prescription was found in her car. The vehicle she drove was found parked and abandoned at a church (the Pleasant Ridge Baptist Church). An eyewitness said he saw a "white Isuzu pickup pull into the church parking lot behind Lofton" (Page 3, April 2nd 1995 Longview News-Journal).


Jeanette Kamahele (NamUs MP#8069) vs. NamUs UP#7765

By: Shane Lambert

Missing Person: Jeannette Kamahele
Last seen or contact date: April 25th, 1972 in the morning, around 930am
Where last seen: Cotati, California on the ramp of Highway 101

NamUs # and Link: #MP8069

Jeannette Kamahele missing report 2
Jeannette Kamahele missing report 2 Fri, Apr 28, 1972 – 2 · The Press Democrat (Santa Rosa, California) · Newspapers.com

I had a look at Jeanette Kamahele's case tonight. This is a missing-person's case that will be fairly well known to websleuths and those familiar with unsolved mysteries in the United States. Kamahele has been included in the often-discussed Santa Rosa Hitchhiker Murders from several decades ago.

I won't review the details of her case too much because they have been covered. You can visit the following link to read about the murders that may have been the work of one serial killer if you wish:

http://www.santarosahitchhikermurders.com.

What I will do is look at Jeanette's case and compare it to an Unidentified Person's case (ie. UP), that being Namus UP#7765. There are three stark similarities between Jeanette and UP#7765 that indicate that the two separate profiles should be looked at as being the same person.

Firstly, there is a modern reconstruction of the UP's face from early in 2018. NamUs has had a bust of the UP for years but now we can have a look at an artist's rendition of the deceased UP#7765 (left) and compare it to Kamahele's pictures below. When I do that I see similar features, including complexion, hair length, and hair-parting point. As far as facial matches between photos and reconstructions go, it's a very intriguing match-up.

Unidentified Person #7765 on the left. Jeanette Kamahele on the right side and middle.

Secondly, an important detail with this case is that the deceased on the left, UP#7765, was found with a sandal near her. Importantly, Jeanette Kamahele on the right, MP#8069, was last seen wearing sandals.

Thirdly, UP#7765 was found with Levi brand denim blue jeans near her body. Jeanette was last seen wearing the Levi's brand, according to her NamUs profile. It does not state that she was wearing Levi's jeans but that is that company's common product.

The time and space match reasonably well between these cases. The decedent was found July 24th, 1976 and was believed to have died between 1966 and 1976. Jeanette went missing in 1972 so the dates definitely match up.

In terms of proximity, we are talking about a difference of 572 miles between Colati, California and a point northward in Oregon. While that might seem like a great distance, it should not be too bothersome because Jeanette was believed to be hitchhiking when she disappeared. In fact, someone who knew her was going to stop and pick her up except someone else did first. That person that picked her up might have been heading a long way north.

There are some problems with these two cases as a potential match. I will note a 5" discrepancy in height between the missing person and the UP, a discrepancy in race, and that not all the clothes overlap between the two profiles. However, the deceased individual had her torso missing so how reliable a height estimation is without a spine is for all to guess. Additionally, when we take NamUs information with a grain of salt and instead look at the original reporting from 1976 we find that there IS NO HEIGHT DISCREPANCY at all.

August 1, 1976 Statesman Journal/Page 33/No author listed/"Linn DA seeking body's identity

The contradiction between races may not be that important. Kamahele was Hawaiian and the UP is described as caucasian. However, the sketch of the UP looks a little swarthy to me. I'm not convinced that a decedent's race can be pinpointed with bones, especially since so many people have mixed backgrounds.

The ages match-up between the profiles. NamUs lists a broad range of between 18-40 years old for the UP and Jeanette's age is within that range (she was 20). But I will note that when the Unidentified Person's bones were originally examined back in 1976 they had a much narrower range. See the clipped article excerpt below which is from the August 1, 1976 Statesman Journal in Salem, Oregon:



Technically, Jeanette's age was out of the 17-19-year-old range but that's not that important because these ranges have to be taken loosely.

The faces also match up in terms of likeness in my view. One detail that I especially like is where the hair parts.

One question that we should be asking is this: how many Unidentified Persons are there out there that look like Jeanette and that were found with the clothing she was last seen in? If you answer "none" then I think you agree with me that UP#7765 is a clear candidate for a rule out in the semi-famous case of Jeanette Kamahele's disappearance.

Another question you could ask is simply if matching the profile of Kamahele to UP#7765 is simply worth taking a shot at just due to how cold the case is. It has been 46 years since Kamahele went missing and if her case isn't solved soon then it stands to reason that many will soon just dismiss it as too archaic to bother with.

Shani Ann Estes (NamUs MP#1204) vs. UP#5963

By: Shane Lambert

Shani Ann Estes has been missing since 2005, that much is clear. However, there is some contradictory information out there from governmental sources as to the date she was last seen. NamUs (she's MP#1204) says she was last seen on November 24th, 2005. The State of California's Department of Justice's website says she was last seen on December 7th, 2005. Regardless, there's reason to consider her as a match to UP#5963.


Shani, according to CharleyProject's profile for her, had an argument with her husband on November 24th, 2005 and then disappeared. The suggestion at that website is that the husband is not a suspect and that Shani left on her own accord.

On the night of January 10th, 2006 a woman known as UP#5963 was found deceased in a burned-out apartment in San Francisco. The distance between where Shani was last seen and this apartment is about 290 miles in the same state of California. 

The time elapsed between the date of the fire and when Shani was last seen depends on what date we go by. We are looking at just over a month if we go by December 7th, 2005 or a month and a half if we go by November 24th, 2005. Regardless, there's no reason to rule one other out yet as possible matches.

UP#5963 is described as not recognizable because of burns suffered in the apartment fire. Accordingly, all physical descriptions have to be taken with a grain of salt.

But the dead individual is listed as a female that was white and that matches Shani. The heights between Shani and the decedent are just 1 inch off and that makes them a match from that point of view because heights are often estimated.

The age of the deceased UP could not really be estimated but she was considered to be an adult. The weight between Shani and the decedent appears to be well off, a full 40 pounds. Furthermore, the eye color is off between the two.

But what's interesting about UP#5963, someone who had brown eyes according to NamUs, was that she was ruled-out against MP#490, a person who had blue eyes. The basis for the rule out may have been a scar: UP#5963 had a scar on her lower-right abdomen and the MP had a scar as well.

That the Unidentified Person with brown eyes was compared to a missing person with blue eyes suggests that the authorities aren't confident in one of the two's eye colors. That may have something to do with the fact that the UP was burned to death. Can you accurately get eye color from charred remains?

MP#490, the rule-out of the UP, went missing in June of 1996 in Arizona. That's far away from San Francisco and the time factor is large, nearly a full decade. If MP#490 can be looked at as a possible match to UP#5963 then surely Shani can.

Shani was much closer to UP#5963 in terms of time and space. Furthermore, Shani may have had a scar right where the Unidentified Person had one. Shani is described as having a "surgical scar" from a c-section, a scar that would be on her abdomen and possibly her lower-right abdomen according to some pictures I googled of c-section scars. The UP had a scar on the lower-right abdomen -- perhaps from the same c-section?

These two are worth a look at despite the mismatching eye color in my opinion. If they aren't one and the same then at least they should be listed as rule outs of one another to prevent future work on the possible match.

NamUs UP#13280 and UP#13278

By: Shane Lambert

I spent some time reading about two cases of unidentified people tonight, cases from January of 2003. The cases may be related although NamUs does not connect them. They are NamUs UP#13280 and UP#13278.

The former was found in Imperial County on January 2nd, 2003 and believed to be dead for five months. The latter was found in the same county on January 7th, 2003 and also believed to be dead for five months. The zip codes associated with the deaths are about 9.4 miles apart according to Google Maps. Both decedents were described as being found in the "open desert."

UP#13280 was found near a jacket that had The Master Palette logo on it. Anyone working on this case may want to know that the logo is associated with Glidden Professional, a paint company. The first snippet below shows the logo on the decedent's jacket while the second snippet shows the logo inset into a website (webpage was active at time of writing). They are remarkably similar.



With UP#13278, I did some research on the most striking feature of this deceased person's remains. She had gold star inlays on her front dentures. In an article published on April 4th, 2007 at the Houston Press, author Olivia Flores Alvarez regales a story of an individual he met in March of that year who had gold star inlays on her front teeth. That person can't be UP#13278 because this UP died in 2002. However, according to Alvarez the gold star inlays are "a popular fashion in highland Guatemala." The title of the article is "Packing Meat" and the topic is illegal immigrant workers.



The relevance is that UP#13278 may have originated from highland Guatemala. This region is in southern Guatemala. It lays between the Sierra Madre de Chiapas to the south and the Petén lowlands to the north.

Anyone working on these cases should be aware of connections to Glidden Professional and to the highlands of Guatemala.

Recently Missing as of April 26th, 2018 - Gitti Wayezi, Kanina Manchester, Karen Savanah Toth








NamUs UP #17575 vs. Venika Williams (no NamUs profile)

By: Shane Lambert





Venika Williams, a missing person, has a Facebook group dedicated to her missing-person's case. Her disappearance was also covered in the news recently. Lastly, she had a NamUs page created in 2019.

The details that I gathered from those sources was that she was last seen on December 22nd, 2017 or the 23rd. She was 28 years old at that time. She is an African-American woman. Her approximate height is 5'3" and her approximate weight is 142 pounds according to a news source. The Facebook group affiliated with her disappearance offered these details:

"VENIKA WILLIAMS WAS LAST SEEN BETWEEN DEC 22-23 2017 . SHE IS FROM NEWARK NJ , FRIENDS SAY THEY BELIEVE SHE WAS IN JERSEY CITY LAST BEING HELD AGAINST HER WILL BY AN UNIDENTIFIED MALE, AS SHE SENT HER LAST TEXT STATING SO ! SHE IS 28 YRS OF AGE , 5’4 , ABOUT 130 LBS. VENIKA WAS LAST SEEN WEARING A BLACK LEATHER JACKET,RED HOODIED SWEATSHIRT AND BLUE JEANS.SHE IS THE MOTHER OF FOUR YOUNG CHILDREN !"

Additionally, according to New Jersey Missing Report there are these details:

"Venika’s last known whereabouts were around the 100 block of Dayton Street in Newark.  She was believed to be traveling from Essex County to Jersey City to do someone’s hair.  She was wearing blue jeans, a black, leather jacket, and red sneakers while carrying a red purse before she vanished."


Comparing Venika Williams to NamUs UP #17575



In my opinion, NamUs UP #17575 should be considered as a rule-out candidate for Venika Williams: that means I think there is enough in common for them to be examined as one and the same person. This is a deceased individual found on March 3rd, 2018 at 10:30am. The deceased individual has characteristics in common with Venika Williams.

Below are six points of comparison that would suggest that Venika and the Jane Doe may be one and the same person:
  1. The decedent and Venika have skin color in common: they are both black.
  2. The decedent and Venika have sex in common: they are both females.
  3. The decedent is thought to have died in either 2017 or 2018. While Venika is not known to be dead, certainly her missing-date matches the death date of this unidentified person.
  4. The decedent's weight is estimated to be 133 pounds, which is very close to the weight estimations for Venika.
  5. The decedent's height is estimated to be 5'5" which is close to Venika's height of 5'4". Those that are familiar with missing-person's cases know that being one inch off is not relevant.
  6. The deceased individual was found in Weequahic Park, which is extremely close to where Venika was last seen as per the news source above. Weequahic Park is adjacent to Dayton Street in Newark (in fact they could be viewed as the same location - see mapped screenshot below)
The green area is the park. The blue line is mostly Dayton Street.
There are certainly some "misses" with this case but they might only be slight. Below are some counterpoints that would suggest that the missing-person Venika Williams and the Jane Doe in Weequahic Park are not the same person.
  1. The deceased has short hair while all photos I saw of Venika had long hair. 
  2. The decedent had tattoos, none of which clearly match up to Venika.
Both points certainly carry some weight. However, hair length can be changed. I'm not sure if hair deteriorates in water, but the deceased was found in water. Nonetheless, hair length is not a rule-out criterion precisely because it is so easily alterable. Furthermore, I think Venika might have used wigs a lot or else she changed hair color a lot.

With regard to the tattoos, I don't know what to think. When it comes to looking at a deceased person's tattoos it can be hard to make them out. For instance, the Jane Doe that was found in Weequahic Park was in water maybe for several months. They did not take photographs of her tattoos and post them to NamUs, which is what they normally do. Instead, they used an artist's rendition of the tattoos. That tells me that the tattoos might have been hard to see.

The deceased had three stars tattooed on her neck. I couldn't find any clear photos of Venika that had such. However, Venika was into tattoos - this is clear from her photographs. Unfortunately, part of the reason I don't know what to think is that there's some inconsistent reporting regarding her tattoos. For example, one source says that Venika had a "Tanesha" tattoo on her right hand. Another source says the same tattoo was on her left hand. 

The deceased had a tattoo that may have read "Tiana." Some might say that's a different tattoo and it was stated to be in a different location than either hand. But whether the word was clearly legible on a body that is described as decomposed for months is debatable. Even so, the sad truth is that missing person's cases are so riddled with such sloppiness that I wouldn't be too deterred by a tattoo being present or not. Writing as someone that has submitted dozens of clerical-error corrects to NamUs, I won't rule-out someone on the basis of a tattoo.

The Jane Doe and Venika match up closely in other ways. In a way, the presence of tattoos unifies them. But there are the other six points to consider. The deceased is thought to have died at about the time when Venika went missing and in the exact same area. With height, weight, race, and sex aligning then certainly those that know Venika will want to be aware of NamUs #17575. 






Keep in mind that the sketch above was made from an individual deceased and decomposed for months. She was also found in a watery location. The photo to the right is of Venika. If she is wearing a wig, as I suspect she is, then her natural hair would be very short. Furthermore, I think I see the star tattoos in the neck area (see the video below for a closer look at the neck). However, one person that knew Venika said she didn't have such a tattoo.

New to NamUs - Maudie Smith MP #42828

Update: Maudie Smith was found deceased. The body that was found that was mentioned in this article ended up being her's.

Related news.

Maudie Smith's NamUs profile was added yesterday, March 29th, 2018.  She has not been seen since February 22nd of 2017, making the gap between her last-seen time and profile-created time mid-lengthed.

Maudie Smith

  • She is a white female
  • She was 37 years old at the time of her disappearance
  • She is 5'4" to 5'6"
  • She is between 130 to 140 pounds
  • She has brown hair and blue eyes
  • She has an "Austin" tattoo on her left arm in black letters
  • She has her daughter's name on her left leg
  • She also has a Leo zodiac sign and a Chinese symbol in purple on her neck
  • They do not have DNA at the time of writing, meaning any Jane Doe profile is a potential match provided it can't be ruled out in other ways
  • According to NamUs she was last seen in Viper, Kentucky walking on Bear Lane* on the right fork of Maces Creek (some Google Map images of that area are below).

*might actually be Bears Lane

There are a few details to clear up from her NamUs profile. They list her as 37 to 38 years old at the time of her disappearance. According to her Facebook profile, she was born August 3rd, 1979 which would make her 37 and not 38 at the time of her disappearance in February of 2017. Also "Bear Lane" might actually be called "Bears Lane." The Google Maps coordinates are 37.163718, -83.179434 for the spot where she was last seen and the area is heavily forested. As far as I can see there are two possibly distinct roads called "Bears Lane" but maybe they are connected through the forest. You can't drop down to street level in this area.



Looking at her Facebook profile


The following details can be found at her Facebook profile, one that is still active at time of writing.


  • She had a "single" status
  • Her nickname was Blue
  • She may associate with the last name "Couch" (the URL for her name is http://facebook.com/maudiecouch)
  • She only lists Hazard, Kentucky as a place where she has lived
  • If you hover over the last-posting time at her account it shows a posting to the Facebook profile at 8:34pm on February 22nd, 2017; however, someone I spoke to through social media that was close to the missing person said that more than one person had access to her Facebook profile and the posts may not have been manually made by Maudie

They did find human remains in the area of Bears Lane on April 16th, 2017.  They know few details of this Jane Doe except that she was a female, she was 30-50 years old, and she was white. This Jane Doe is NamUs UP #16583. They have the Jane Doe's DNA so a DNA sample from Smith or a family member may help crack this case.




NamUs MP #31134 - Peggy McGuire

By: Shane Lambert

Peggy McGuire is NamUs MP #31134. She went missing on November 16th, 2015 (Monday) and her NamUs profile was created 8 days later. That is a very-short gap between her last-seen time and her profile-created time, an indication that everyone familiar with this case has treated her disappearance as credible (ie. not a voluntary disappearance). As of January 2021 Peggy is still missing and a large Facebook group has been created for the purpose of bringing her home.

Peggy McGuire

According to NamUs, Peggy is missing from Eufaula, Oklahoma. That is a small lake-side town about two hours to the east of Oklahoma City and an hour and twenty minutes south of Tulsa, Oklahoma. The Arkansas state border is about 90 minutes to 105 minutes to the east by driving.

Thu, Dec 10, 2015 – 5 · The Daily Oklahoman (Oklahoma City, Oklahoma) · Newspapers.com

Peggy, according to her NamUs profile, was last seen dropping her son off at school. Her NamUs profile also contains these details, some of which may be slightly off.


  • She was 28 years old at the time of the disappearance
  • She is a white female
  • Her height is about 70 inches (5'10")
  • Her weight is 150 to 160 pounds 
  • Her shoe size was 10 
  • She had blonde/strawberry hair and blue eyes 
  • She had a scar on her right knee
  • She had a tattoo on her lower back (horseshoe with stars, four leaf clover, and the initials JNS).
  • She also had pierced ears
  • She last spoke with her stepfather by phone and was supposed to phone back with measurements for a new deck (according to a news report by Rachel Trost of NBC)


Her DNA status is complete. That means that anyone looking at this case involving a Jane Doe should focus on Jane Does where they do NOT have completed DNA tests. The reason for that is that if they have completed tests on a Doe then the computerized systems will make the match.

A case wrought with contradictory information


Amateurs working on this case may have their efforts hurt by the fact that there is contradictory information online regarding her case. In the event that there is a contradiction, you cannot take for granted that NamUs has the correct information.

The poster below, which advertises a large reward, says that Peggy was last seen at "her home in Stidham, OK" (as opposed to at her son's school in Eufala....). There is only a 12-mile difference between Stidham and Eufala, however, they are distinct towns requiring rural highway travel to go between. Another source (Rachel Trost with NBC) says "Monday marks two weeks since Peggy McGuire was last seen dropping her young son off at school outside Eufaula, Oklahoma."

Furthermore, the poster below says that she was 29 at the time of her disappearance (not 28....), it says her hair was blonde (not strawberry blonde....), and her weight is listed as 140 lbs (which is outside the 150 to 160 range....). Hopefully, the police would have correct information but someone has treated accuracy in a frivolous manner regarding this case.

Ahead of clarifying these details use this information:


  • 28-29 years old at the time of the disappearance
  • 140 to 160 pounds
  • Missing from the Eufaula area
  • Blonde or strawberry-blonde hair

Anyone with intimate and personal knowledge of this case should make an effort to get NamUs to correct the profile. A profile with incorrect information can throw off any user of the NamUs system. For example, if a decedent woman is found, let's say, 500 miles away from Eufaula and her estimated age range is 29 years old to 39 years old then someone using that search criterion for missing person's would actually miss Peggy's profile because they have her as a 28-year old (an age that I think is wrong).




Despite the fact that McGuire went missing while operating a vehicle, NamUs contains no information regarding her vehicle description. Her vehicle is no longer missing but it is central to a significant lead. It was a Toyota Truck according to one source I read and appears to be white, although footage can obscure color (if you know the make and model or information about the vehicle please post it in the comments, with credentials please).

According to one poster I found, on November 17th, 2015 (1 day after she went missing), Peggy's truck was found at one "T&J's Ice House." This bar has Google Maps coordinates of 35.306088, -95.664516. The poster claims that a man on surveillance was seen parking the truck and then walking away from it at 5am in the morning. This mystery man may certainly be the individual that disappeared Peggy. The matter regarding the truck was covered by Fox News on May 23rd, 2017 (and possibly earlier).


According to the article: "McGuire’s truck was found at an ice house about 10 miles away from her home shortly after she disappeared.

Surveillance cameras captured McGuire’s truck driving into the parking lot. A few seconds later, a figure can be seen getting out and walking away.

Friends and family members say McGuire doesn’t drink, so there’s no reason why she would drive herself to the ice house" (POSTED 10:06 AM, MAY 23, 2017, BY KFOR-TV & K. QUERRY).

Peggy's Facebook profile remains active at time of writing. She described herself as a licensed practical nurse and I've seen a photo of her in a nurse's uniform.

Commentary


In this case, I will presume that the man on surveillance at T&J's Ice House probably disappeared McGuire. Presumptions like that can be dangerous but, unfortunately, conjecture is all that's available.



The man, according to the poster, dropped the truck off at 5am on November 17th. Peggy went missing, according to NamUs, at 10:15 the previous day.

Accordingly, there is about a 19-hour gap between her last-seen time and the drop off of the truck at TJ's. If we assume that the individual that drove the truck slept for at least six hours between her last-seen time and 5am on November 17th then there are 13 hours of activity to account for. That means that during that time the man could not have gotten more than 6.5 hours of driving time away from the last-seen location and TJ's while staying in the company of McGuire, either alive or dead. That could have search-area implications if we assume that McGuire was murdered on November 16th, 2015.

The individual that dropped the truck off need not be affiliated with the ice house. It's possible that he understood that dropping the truck at the local 'dodgy joint' would take the investigation toward patrons of that establishment.

Resemblances to other cases of missing people


Case resemblances do not mean that the cases are linked. However, history does repeat itself. Information from one case might provide food for thought on other similar cases, even across a significant amount of time and space. These cases are meant to facilitate speculation and critical thought.

Jennifer Kesse

There are resemblances between the cases of Peggy Anne McGuire and Jennifer Kesse, the latter being one of the more-famous American missing-person's cases of this century thus far. Jennifer Kesse went missing at the age of 24 in 2006 and she remains missing to date, NamUS MP #1342. Kesse was a blonde, white, female, in her 20s. Kesse, at 5'8" to 5'9", was about the same height as McGuire.
But a more interesting connection to the case is that Kesse's vehicle was discovered a short-time after she disappeared. The individual that parked Kesse's car was seen walking away from it on video surveillance and has not yet been identified. In this way, the case bears a striking resemblance to McGuire's: the identity of the individual in the video-tape surveillance is a frustrating missing puzzle piece in each case.

Holly Cantrell

Holly Cantrell is missing from nearby McAlester, Oklahoma (about 40 miles south of Eufaula). Cantrell went missing in the late morning, like McGuire. Furthermore, Cantrell shared a nursing profession and she went missing at a similar-enough time (ie. January 20th, 2017). Cantrell is missing person #37166 at NamUs. They may have a lead on Cantrell from February 2018.

Rosa Lisowski

Rosa Lisowski is a missing person last seen in San Diego. She dropped her child off at school and has not been heard from since. In Lisowski's case, which is NamUs MP #5548, someone close to her has been central to the investigation.




Joseph Anthony Stuart (NamUs #29973) - 2nd attempt

By: Shane Lambert

Almost two years ago I made an attempt at NamUs MP #29973, an individual named Joseph Anthony Stuart who has not been seen since September 6th, 1991. I considered Stuart as a possible match for NamUs UP #7582 but the match was ruled out based on dental comparisons. Otherwise, a lot of things aligned between the John Doe and the Missing Person #29973: they had similar demographics and the John Doe was found along one possible route that Stuart, the missing person, might have traveled to get to Reno. Word was that he was heading that way to look into a job prospect.

The rule out, as always, was final the moment it came back to me: it's hard to argue with something like dental comparisons. They and fingerprinting used to be sacred in identifying human remains in the era before DNA. But I think I found another candidate for a rule-out attempt on Joseph Anthony Stuart: NamUs UP #2294. Firstly, here's a recap of Stuart's demographics and circumstances.

  • He was last seen on September 6th, 1991
  • He was 35 years old at the time of his disappearance
  • He was a white male
  • He was 68" inches, which is 5'8"
  • His hair color was brown and his eyes were blue
  • He was last seen in Fullerton, California
  • His landlord reported him missing on September 26th, 1991
  • He seemed to participate in suicidal ideation
  • He had told the landlord that he was going fishing
  • On September 6th, 1991 Stuart also told a friend that he was going to Reno for an employment prospect
It's the route to Reno, or routes, that have interested me. Earlier tonight, I was reminded of Stuart's case when I looked at NamUs UP #2294. That's mainly because the reconstruction of UP #2294 actually reminded me of the reconstruction of UP #7582. When I looked at the profiles I began to wonder if it could be Stuart.

NamUs UP #2294



UP #2294 was found on July 8th, 2008. He has been ruled-out already against eight different individuals with birthdates ranging from 1950 to 1978. That big range is a pretty big clue that they don't know the UP's age and NamUs suggests that it's anywhere between 25 and 45 years old. For starters, Stuart is dead-smack in the middle of that range which seems promising.

UP #2294 is described this way at NamUs: "a white male adult, estimated to be between 25 and 45 years of age. It is estimated that he was born between 1955 and 1973. He died sometime between 1989 and 1998. The victim is estimated to have stood between 5'6" and 5'9"."

The race and sex match to Stuart. The estimated date of birth matches to Stuart and the estimated date of death is in the range that would match up to Stuart's disappearance and, maybe, his death date. Furthermore, Stuart was 5'8" and that is in the John Doe's height range. 

The John Doe, NamUs UP #2294, was found near highway 15. He was buried and skeletonized. The clothes that he had do not match Stuart's last-known clothes but clothes change all the time. Importantly, this John Doe was found on a route that one might take between Fullerton and Reno. 

The image below shows that I searched for directions between Fullerton and Reno. The blue line is the route that one could take. I didn't include Reno in the map snip because I wanted to include a close-up of the area that the decedent was found in. If you see where it says "Lytle Creek" in the top-right quadrant, that is near where the John Doe was found.


That means there is an alignment between Stuart and the John Doe in several ways:

  1. Age
  2. Sex
  3. Race
  4. Height
  5. Estimated date of death for the Doe vs. Stuart's disappearance date
  6. Stuart could be placed in the area if his friend's comment that he was going to Reno from Fullerton is taken to be accurate.
They have dentals for the UP and I know they have Stuart's because they were a rule-out criterion the last time I submitted. I think I will submit this John Doe again and will let you know how it goes with an update.


NamUs UP #17549 vs NamUs MP #34827 (Stephanie Hunsberger)

In this article, a comparison and contrast will be made between an Unidentified Person (UP) and a Missing Person (MP). Attempts to rule out the possibility that the UP is the MP will be made. That failing, the MP and UP may end up being one and the same person.

NamUs UP #17549


NamUs's UP #17549 is an individual with a very problematic profile. This deceased female was found in garbage bags bound with an electrical cord in Philadelphia. The individual was found on June 2nd, 1980 and her profile was uploaded to NamUs on March 7th, 2018. That's a very large gap relative to many other profiles.

She was found in a vacant house, her head was not recovered, and one or more limbs was not recovered. Although she was found on June 2nd, 1980 she was believed to had died sometime between 1978 and 1980. Her height was estimated at 68 inches (5'8") but the estimation has to be taken loosely based on her decomposed state and the absence of her head and maybe even her legs. Her age range is large, between the ages of 20 and 40 years old. The saving grace of this profile is DNA: they have a sample that is not yet processed.


Commentary


When the head and limbs aren't recovered with a clearly murdered decadent it suggests that the victim's murderer made an attempt to keep the decadent's identity hidden from the authorities. In the 1970s and prior, before DNA was popular, teeth and fingerprints were a common method of identification. Whoever put the decadent in the garbage bags may have been concerned about her identity providing a link to the murderer.

Similar UP case: bones found in two bags in Philadelphia in 1979.

NamUs #34827


When the following search parameters are used, there is only one match in NamUs. 

Date last seen: January 1st, 1978 to April 1st, 1980 (I took two months off the higher date because of the decomposed state)
Age last seen: 18 to 42 (note: I used a larger range by two years in each direction relative to the decadent's information)
Sex: female
Height: 66 inches to 70 inches
State: Pennsylvania

That search criteria only brings up Stephanie Hunsberger, an individual with a very-lengthy profile at NamUs. She also lead what seems to be a high-risk lifestyle at the time, with prostitution and drugs a part of her life. Her official last-seen date is February 25th, 1978 according to NamUs but there are those that have told authorities she was alive in 1979. 

They have a completed DNA sample for Stephanie. If she is the decadent in the corded garbage bags then, once the decadent's DNA is processed, the match will likely be made.

NamUs #22939


Another potential match is NamUs #22939. She is Jennifer Prince, an individual who has been missing since November 18th, 1978. Prince's height is just one inch off of 68" and her age is in the range, She went missing in New Jersey, which is just across the state line from where the decedent was found. She is missing from a city called Brick, about 66 miles away from where the decedent was found. DNA is available in Prince's case as well.

Adam Christopher Patterson Missing Person Case Details - NamUs #MP42783

By: Shane Lambert
Original time of writing: March 27th, 2018

Adam Christopher Patterson was new to NamUs at the time of writing. However, he has been missing for about 2.5 years as of the publication date. Furthermore, several years have passed since I originally published this blog post. Adam Patterson will soon have been missing for ten years. In the embedded picture below, readers will find his case details.

This is someone who could be lost at sea. The missing person poster above states that the Maine Marine Patrol could be contacted with information. He is missing from Portland, Maine and is believed to have taken a water taxi (he was a licensed captain) out to sea. The boat was later located washed up on a beach in Kennebunk."

The over land distance using highway travel from Portland to Kennebunk is just under 30 miles. Perhaps the nautical displacement or distance traveled is more relevant though. The beach that the boat washed up on was called Parson's Beach as per news coverage from late 2015.


Patterson's last-seen time as per NamUs is November 10th, 2015. However, the news source above says he spoke to his wife at 1:30am on November 11th, 2015 over the phone. Security footage shows Patterson leaving the dock at 3:30am.


Commentary

The authorities believe Patterson to be dead based on weather conditions and the condition of the boat. Lost at sea could actually mean lost for all time. This could be a futile case for online researchers to try and find a clue in. It seems that there is a working idea of what happened to him.

I would think that if he were found, then it would be skeletal remains that others, beside online researchers, would work on. That said, there's no harm in cross-referencing his details against unidentified John Does from time to time.
Adam Christopher Patterson Missing Person Case Details - NamUs #MP42783

Adam Christopher Patterson: Detailed NamUs Case Summary

Category Details
Case Number NamUs #MP42783
Full Name Adam Christopher Patterson
Biological Sex Male
Race / Ethnicity White / Caucasian
Date of Last Contact November 10, 2015
Missing From Portland, Maine (Cumberland County)
Missing Age 30 Years
Current Age 40 Years (as of March 29, 2025)
NamUs Case Created March 26, 2018
Height 5' 8" (68 inches)
Weight 145 lbs
Hair Color Brown
Eye Color Blue (both left and right)
Distinctive Features Circular scar on back, scar on right cheek
Circumstances Believed to have taken a water taxi (licensed captain) out to sea; boat later found washed up on a beach in Kennebunk

Featured Post

Missing Person: Lisa Marie Knight - Ossineke, Michigan 2012 Disappearance

Missing Person : Lisa Marie Knight ...

Best of MPC (as selected by the site's author)