Missing Person Case: Brenda Louise Condon

Missing Person Case: Brenda Louise Condon
Name	Brenda Louise Condon (one of her middle names appeared as "Coon" in an article) Not to be confused: there was a Brenda Condon who had a warrant out for her arrest but her middle name was Valetta.
Date of Last Contact	NamUs: February 27, 1991 (Wednesday) at about 00:45am Centre Daily Times: February 26, 1991 (Tuesday) Due to her disappearance close to midnight, it was probably Tuesday-night but after midnight so technically Wednesday that she went missing.
Missing From	Bellefonte, Pennsylvania (Centre County) Carl's Bad Tavern (was along State Route 550 in Spring Township/went out of business later that same year)
Age at Disappearance	28 Years
Current Age	63 Years
Birthdate Range	February 28, 1962 - February 27, 1963 (based on being 28 years old on the night she went missing. Birthdate is listed as February 1962 (Ancestry). Only February 28th, 1962 fits in the range, making that her probable birthdate. At any rate, it was close to her birthday.
Biological Sex	Female
Race / Ethnicity	White / Caucasian
Height	5'3" - 5'5" (63 - 65 Inches)
Weight	110 - 120 lbs
Hair Color	Reddish-brown Shoulder lengthed hair
Eye Color	Light blue (wearing green contact lenses)
Distinctive Physical Features	Pierced ears; Tattoo of a ring of roses on right ankle
Clothing and Accessories	Green contact lenses; Cowboy boots found in men's restroom. Was wearing a silver shirt over a black tank top and jeans with silver studs.
Circumstances of Disappearance	Last seen working as a bartender at Carl's Bad Tavern, SR 550, Spring Township, Centre County, Pennsylvania, around 12:45 AM on February 27, 1991. She was alone at the bar. The tavern was found abandoned and unlocked later that day, with no signs of struggle or crime. Her car was in the parking lot, and her cowboy boots were found in the men's restroom. NamUs says she had been working at the bar for a couple of days. Other sources, say a couple of weeks.
NamUs Case Number	MP2902
NamUs Case Created	October 8, 2009 (Thursday)

By: Shane Lambert

Original time of publishing: October 7th, 2025

Brenda Louise Condon went missing under suspicious circumstances. She was working at a bar during the late shift on February 26th, 1991. She was last seen at about 0045am by bar patrons on February 27th, 1991. Her car was found in the parking lot the next morning, the establishment she was in charge was unlocked, and her boots were found in the men's room for some reason. Condon has not been seen or heard from since.

Centre Daily Times. March 7th, 1991.

There was a lot of media coverage for this case. I used it to enhance the details at NamUs. The journalism listed her address as 1959 Harvest Circle in State College, Pennsyvania. I did find an Ancestry profile matching the name and street address,which also listed some other addresses in the area.

Missing Person: Marla Jean Thomas - Anacortes, WA 1974 Unsolved Case

Missing Person: Marla Jean Thomas (nee Crabtree)

Details from a government source (might be paraphrased):

Marla Jean Thomas was last seen on December 11th, 1974 (Wednesday) in Anacortes, Washington (specific location unknown).

Last contact: December 11th, 1974, approximately, unknown specific time
Last location: Anacortes, Washington(may be 511 T Avenue in Anacortes)
Age when Marla Jean Thomas disappeared: 22
DOB: April 22nd, 1952 (Charley Project)
Sex: Female
Height in inches: 62
Weight in pounds (lbs): 140
BMI: 25.6 - Overweight (calculated to help picture what Marla Jean Thomas might have looked like)
Ethnicity: White / Caucasian
Hair color: Brown
Eye Color: Blue
Link to Government Source: NamUs MP31485 (right-click to open)
Discussion page: Marla Jean Thomas Case on Facebook (right-click to open)

Family: Alfred P. Thomas Jr. (husband); there was a divorce record after she disappeared (initiated by husband) on August 20th, 1976.

March 24th, 1970. The Daily Herald.

Unraveling the Mystery: Key Insights and Updates

By: Shane Lambert
Original time of writing: August 18th, 2025
October 15th, 2025: There are some statements online at Websleuths suggesting that this person was identified. The article below is unchanged from my original publicaton on August 18th, 2025 but readers should be aware that there is potential for this article to change.

Marla Jean Thomas, a 22-year-old White/Caucasian woman, vanished on Wednesday, December 11th, 1974, from Anacortes, Washington, under mysterious circumstances. Standing 5'2" and weighing approximately 140 pounds, Marla had brown hair, blue eyes, and a BMI of 25.6, indicating a slightly overweight build.

No distinctive physical features or clothing details are mentioned in her NamUs profile. Furthermore, her exact last known location in Anacortes, Washington remains unspecified.

Anacortes, located on Fidalgo Island in Skagit County, is a picturesque coastal town about 80 miles north of Seattle, known for its stunning views of the San Juan Islands, vibrant maritime culture, and small-town charm. This would be a close-knit community in Puget Sound.

I did not find a missing persons report in the journalism from the time of her disappearance. However, I do recommend looking through the Facebook group that I hyperlinked. She was married with three children.

On thing that stood out with this case is that she and her husband were involved in a lawsuit against a local company, one that started just 2-3 months before Marla's disappearance. 

September 28th, 1974. Kitsap Sun.

Liverpool Mother’s Newborn Killing Confession: A Cold Case Echoing Other Tragedies

By: Shane Lambert
Original time of writing: March 24th, 2025

Baby Callum’s Tragic End

In recent news, a 55-year-old woman in Liverpool, England has admitted to killing her newborn son back in the late 1990s. The body of an infant was found in 1998.

Although the attempt to identify the newborn initially failed, DNA did connect the baby to his living brother. That helped investigators piece together what happened.

Joanne Sharkey confessed in 2023 to killing her son, dubbed Callum, found in bin bags near Gulliver’s World in Warrington. Forensic evidence showed asphyxiation from tissue paper in his mouth. DNA eventually linked Callum to Sharkey’s son, Matthew, leading to her arrest.

Source: Open Country/Alejandro Josan/March 24th, 2025

A Secret Birth Unraveled

Reportedly, Sharkey hid her pregnancy, gave birth alone, and silenced Callum (not the baby's real name) in panic, later admitting it to her husband, Neil. It's this latter conversation that was pivotal in understanding what happened as it was recorded. Her charge shifted from murder to manslaughter due to postnatal depression. She awaits sentencing with family support.

Down and Out in the Canadian Rockies

A BLEAK GLIMPSE INTO RESORT TOWN LIFE FROM A WORKER'S PERSPECTIVE

Get your copy of this engaging ebook now

Available on Amazon for Kindle or as a physical copy

Buy Now (Canada) Buy Now (USA)

Why This Case is Important to the True Crime Readers

This case is just one example of many cases where a mother or parent murders a newborn child. This is a scenario that true crime readers need to be familiar with.

I’ve studied many John Doe and Jane Doe cases where it is very clear that the unidentified person is a newborn. The giveaway is that they are often incredibly light, exceptionally short for an estimated height, wrapped, and discarded like Callum. In these cases, I have suspected parental panic, a pattern Sharkey’s story fits perfectly. I'm sure my suspicions in these cases will align with everyone else's.

Here are some other cases that mirror this tragedy, showing a recurring theme of concealment. Below is a small table of examples where mothers killed newborns and hid the remains:

Name	Location	Year	Details
Megan Huntsman	Utah, USA	1996-2006	Strangled/suffocated six newborns, hid them in garage boxes; got life in 2015. Source: Utah County Attorney's News
Andrea G.	Germany	2000s	Killed eight newborns, wrapped them in towels, hid them at home; charged in 2016. Source: BBC article from 2016
Michele Kalina	Pennsylvania, USA	1996-2010	Hid five newborns’ remains in a closet after killing them; got 20-40 years in 2011. Source: CBC article from 2011

Resolution’s Rarity

I rarely work on these kinds of cases since secret newborns lack missing persons reports. Obviously, if the mother kills her own child, she isn't going to have an interest in reporting her baby missing. I can't think of much of a research angle for such cases.

Identification mainly looks like it will be dependent on, not just forensics, but the police having the time and resources to pursue the investigation. In my opinion, the number of discarded newborns in any nation will be shockingly high.

At the time of writing, if you went to NamUs and searched unidentified remains as either infant or fetus, then you would get 606 results. That is just a small sample, capturing only the cases that end up digitalized. Some of them go back 80 years now, highlighting the unlikelihood of resolution.

Politically, I think the cases relate to the topic of abortion. It's important not to overgeneralize as not all the cases would be related to the topic.