Showing posts with label uncollected money. Show all posts
Showing posts with label uncollected money. Show all posts

Robby Peay Cold Case Solved: An Uncollected Inheritance Suggested Tragedy

42-Year-Old Mystery Resolved: Robby Peay Identified in Arches National Park

By: Shane Lambert
March 20th, 2025

This article is part of a short-term series where I do deep dives at some solved cases to see the circumstances. Click on the label "Deep Dive at a Solved Case" to see other similar articles.

On March 20th, 2025, True Crime News reported that a decades-old cold case had been solved. The Provo Police Department identified human remains found in the Utah desert in 1983 as those of Robby Lynn Peay. He was a 17-year-old who disappeared in 1982.

Peay's historical missing person case described a runaway from a youth treatment center in Salt Lake City on October 7th, 1982. He was reported missing after failing to return.

Four months later, a body with a gunshot wound to the head was discovered in Arches National Park, Moab. However, decomposition prevented identification at the time.

The case went cold despite clues like Peay’s truck being found. It was 350 miles away in Lake Powell, which would confuse the link between the body and the truck. His family, presuming the worst, had him declared legally dead in 1990 and placed a cenotaph gravestone in Provo Cemetery.

The mystery persisted for years. In 2018, a Provo Police detective entered Peay’s information into the National Missing and Unidentified Persons System (NamUs). A corrected dental X-ray suggested a match with the Arches John Doe, but DNA confirmation was needed.

Since Peay was adopted at 11 months old with no direct biological relatives in his adopted family, investigators unsealed adoption records and used genealogical testing to locate a biological uncle.

Historical Clues: Newspaper Reports Highlight Peay’s Disappearance and Uncollected Inheritance

Newspaper clippings from The Daily Herald reveal the anguish of Peay’s family during the search. A profile published on February 22nd, 1990, described him as a 24-year-old white male, 5-foot-10 or taller, 150 pounds, with brown hair, blue eyes, fair complexion, and faint scars on his back from a childhood injury. Here is the original clipping from The Daily Herald (February 22, 1990):

MISSING MAN SOUGHT

A 24-year-old Provo man is still missing after seven years. On Oct. 7, 1982, Robby Lynn Peay escaped a Youth Diagnostic Center in Salt Lake City and has not been seen nor heard from since.

Peay has not made contact with his mother or friends since. On March 16, 1984, Mrs. Peay notified the Provo Police Department that she learned her son was in Boulder, Colo., using the name of Bobbert Casper.

A later article from The Daily Herald on December 29th, 1992, noted an inheritance that went uncollected. 

This uncollected money was a significant clue—Peay never claimed it, which, as history shows, often indicates a missing person is deceased. People are typically protective of financial assets with powerful feelings of entitlement. I think the police were very correct to assume he was dead after he failed to collect an inheritance.

Uncollected Money as a Clue: Comparing Peay’s Case to Phyllis Maue and Theresa Yakimchuk

Uncollected money as a clue to death is evident in other cases. Phyllis Maue, missing since 1982, never cashed her work paycheck, as noted in a Missing Persons Commentary blog. Similarly, Theresa Yakimchuk, presumed deceased by friends, never cashed a bank draft she purchased, according to another post on the same blog.

These examples, alongside Peay’s unclaimed inheritance, underscore a pattern. People rarely abandon financial assets willingly. Whether it’s a paycheck, bank draft, or inheritance, such assets are typically safeguarded, making their abandonment a strong indicator of death across all demographics.

However, I think this must be coupled with a lengthy disappearance to avoid overgeneralization. Furthermore, someone might forsake a small monetary asset.

Challenges of Identifying Adopted Missing Persons and the Impact of False Leads

Identifying an adopted missing person like Peay against a John Doe is particularly challenging. Adoption severs biological ties, complicating DNA matches without living relatives. Investigators had to unseal Peay’s adoption records and use genealogical testing, a process that took years and relied on modern forensics unavailable in the 1980s, delaying identification for over four decades. 

The 1984 “Bobbert Casper” lead, where Peay was reportedly seen in Boulder, Colorado, highlights the harm of erroneous tips. This sighting, which was offered after Peay was already dead, diverted resources and prolonged his family’s false hope. Such misinformation underscores the need for verified leads, as uncollected money remains a far more reliable clue in determining a missing person’s fate.

It is another example of how eyewitness sources are simply unreliable. But unfortunately, they must be included in cases where there's simply nothing else to go with.

I will lastly state that sometimes family members are the people most prone to believe false sightings. In my opinion, they will be prone to anything that suggests their family member is not dead. Anyone might behave this way but for those interested in resolving missing persons cases, don't buy into fanciful family stories. This is a matter I've discussed in other cases, particularly the cases of Ricky Jean Bryant and The Sodder Family.


Down and Out in the Canadian Rockies

A BLEAK GLIMPSE INTO RESORT TOWN LIFE FROM A WORKER'S PERSPECTIVE

Get your copy of this engaging ebook now

Available on Amazon for Kindle or as a physical copy

Juanita Migwans Missing - Ontario Woman Not Seen Since October 4th, 2024

Missing Person: Juanita Migwans
Nickname or Alias: Winnie
Details from a government source (might be paraphrased): Juanita Migwans was last seen on October 4th, 2024, on Riverside Drive in the First Nation of M'Chigeeng, Ontario. She did not have her cell phone or bank card. Some sources have said she "lost" them, which would imply accidental misplacing. The last banking activity was on September 25th, 2024. Her family and friends are concerned for her well-being as she hasn't been heard from.


Last contact: October 4th, 2024 (Friday)
Last location: M'Chigeeng First Nation, Ontario, on Manitoulin Island

Age when Juanita Migwans disappeared: 30
Sex: Female
Height in inches: 66
Weight in pounds (lbs): 110 lbs, described as thin or slender, and looks petite in her photos. She would be underweight by BMI standards.

Ethnicity: Indigenous. Pale to slightly swarthy appearance in photos.

Hair color: Brown
Eye Color: Brown
Scar or distinctive characteristic: Tattoos (1) Left Foot, A bird carrying a ribbon with text "THIS TOO SHALL PASS" (2) Left Ankle, A heart.
Link to Government Source: 2024054239 (right click to open)
Websleuths discussion page: Juanita Migwans (right click to open)
Clothing: Dark-colored pants, light-colored jacket.
DOB: December 18th, 1993

Commentary and Research

By
: Shane Lambert
Original time of writing: January 31st, 2025, updates in March 2025

Please note, this is a case with evolving details. As for information accuracy, the only guarantee is that I will try my best, source, and revisit with updates from time-to-time.

Has Juanita Migwans been found?


Juanita Migwans went missing on October 4th, 2024. As of March 24th, 2025, she remains missing.

In recent news at the time of writing, there was a significant reward related to her case. According to a recent CTV News article, "The Ontario Government is offering a $50,000 reward for information leading to the arrest and conviction of those responsible for the disappearance of Juanita Migwans as United Chiefs and Councils of Manitoulin Police Service Commission (UCCM Police) Ontario Provincial Police (OPP) continue their search efforts."

The way the above quotation reads, it sounds as though foul play is suspected. In a more official statement, the police said foul play was not ruled out.

Juanita Migwans went missing from an Indian reserve on Manitoulin Island. This island stands out as the largest island in the world that is in a lake (Lake Huron).

She was last seen on Riverside Drive on the reserve. This is a short segment of roadway. It's not clear what time of day she was last seen or which direction she was heading by the news coverage.

What stands out in this case, is she did not have a phone, bank card, or ID with her when she disappeared. This has some implications. For instance, it would imply that she was not planning on leaving Manitoulin Island. She has not done any banking transactions since September 25th, 2024, which was nine days before her last sighting.

Furthermore, according to news in late March 2025, this individual has uncollected money. This latter point would be ominous based on several other cases involving uncollected money.

There was a previous sighting of her that has been reported in some sources. Some early sources back in November state that she was last seen on October 2nd, 2024 at 10:30am at the intersection of Highway 551 and Oakhill Drive. The latter citing, of October 4th, has been described as a phone call in some sources. I 

There is a social media source that states that she was involved in a court case.



Down and Out in the Canadian Rockies

A BLEAK GLIMPSE INTO RESORT TOWN LIFE FROM A WORKER'S PERSPECTIVE

Get your copy of this engaging ebook now

Available on Amazon for Kindle or as a physical copy

Juanita Migwans Case Update: March 19th, 2025 Developments


As of March 19th, 2025, Juanita "Winnie" Migwans remains missing, but her case has gained significant traction. An update from The Manitoulin Expositor (Jacqueline St.Pierre), reveals that a community-driven billboard campaign was launched to keep her disappearance in the spotlight.

The first billboard went up on Highway 17 on March 14th, 2025, costing $3,500, with a $100,000 reward now offered. This doubled the $50,000 noted earlier. This escalation underscores rising urgency six months after she vanished from M’Chigeeng First Nation on October 4th, 2024.

The March 19th update also ties Juanita’s case to the broader Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women and Girls (MMIWG) crisis. "Missing and murdered aboriginal women" is a tag I use on my blog (which you are looking at right now). You can click the tag if you are interested in other cases involving missing Aboriginal women in Canada.

Credit to St.Pierre and The Manitoulin Expositor for illuminating the billboard effort.

Juanita Migwans Case Update: March 24th, 2025 Developments


As of today, March 24th, 2025, Juanita "Winnie" Migwans remains missing nearly six months after her disappearance on October 4th, 2024. A recent article by Kenneth Armstrong at SooToday.com provides new details on the ongoing efforts to find her. Here’s what’s happening:
  • Her family has launched a GoFundMe campaign to raise funds for three additional billboards—planned for Hwy. 17 between Espanola and Sault Ste. Marie, between Espanola and Sudbury, and Hwy. 69 north of Parry Sound—building on an existing billboard on Manitoulin Island. As of late March 24th, this campaign had raised $5822. Please consider supporting it, noting that even small donations from a lot of people can help them achieve their goals.
  • The article from Kenneth Amstrong says that funds from a Robinson-Huron Treaty settlement remain untouched. I will comment on this shortly.
  • Despite exhaustive searches by Tribal Police and the OPP, no leads have surfaced, prompting volunteer Peggy Simon to speculate about foul play or sex trafficking.
  • Migwans’ case continues to rally her community, who hope the expanded billboard campaign will yield answers.

Credit to Kenneth Armstrong at SooToday.com for this detailed reporting.

Uncollected Money: Often Considered a Major Flag

I have been writing about missing person mysteries for a decade now with research on numerous cases. Uncollected money is often a major flag. In some cases in the past, I know police have considered substantial amounts of uncollected money to strongly suggest that a missing person is deceased.

Migwans' case was serious from the start but that she did not collect her treaty money, as reported in the Armstrong article, is very convincing to me that this is not a voluntary disappearance. I don't think many people are looking at this mystery feeling like she was missing voluntarily but her failure to collect the treaty money should put to bed any notion of a voluntary disappearance.

From what I gathered, the reserve won a settlement and there have been incremental payments made to band members over time. It must be one of these incremental payments that she did not collect.

The "uncollected money" circumstance is one I am trying to build on at my blog. The current posts associated with this theme can be found here.

GoFundMe Campaign Aims to Raise Funds for Awareness


The GoFundMe campaign, titled "Bring Juanita (Winnie) Home - awareness through billboards," organized by Mary-Ann Ashcroft, has raised $5,822 of its $15,000 goal as of the latest update.

This effort underscores the community's determination to keep Juanita's story visible while seeking answers to her disappearance. Furthermore, the diversity of the donors shows that there is a broader concern for her well-being.

Phyllis Maue: Missing Since 1982 - Unsolved Disappearance Case

Missing Person's Name: Phyllis Maue
Middle initial: A.
Last contact: June 25th, 1982 (Friday); reportedly at about 2 PM
Age when she disappeared: 29
Sex: Female
Height in inches: 64 which is 5'4"
Weight in pounds (lbs): 120
Ethnicity: White/Caucasian
Hair color: Red/Auburn, long and shoulder-length
Eye Color: Brown, and can be wearing glasses
Scar or distinctive characteristic: Caesarian scar on abdomen

Family: Gregory Paul (son), Greg Maue (husband)

Details from a government source (might be paraphrased or details added): Phyllis Maue was last seen getting into a light brown Chevrolet Van, one block from her residence. She had a possible destination of New York. She was last seen wearing a red pullover shirt, blue jeans, and gym shoes. These could be cross-referenced to Jane Does on NamUs.



Commentary and Research

By: Shane Lambert

The Day Phyllis Maue Vanished


Phyllis Maue was last seen on June 25th, 1982, which was a Friday.

According to NamUs, she was last seen entering a Chevrolet Van and may have been heading to New York. However, most of the focus on this individual had to do with more local areas where she was last seen. I think searching in New York will likely prove fruitless.

xAI's Grok generated these images when asked to generate an image of a typical Chevrolet Van from the 1977 to 1982 period.

This is a case where I was able to find some journalism on the missing person. Her last known location was in Norwood, Ohio, a suburb or small city to the northeast of Cincinnati, Ohio. A friend last saw her at 2 PM on June 25th, 1982.

The first article on her disappearance that I was able to find appeared in the Cincinnati Enquirer on Wednesday, March 23rd, 1983, titled "Police Ask Help in Finding Woman Missing Since June."

From this article we learn she was married to Greg Maue, she had a ten-year-old son, and that there was a letter from Cincinnati about this case. This letter, which was postmarked to that city, claimed that she was heading to New York City -- which was probably not true, in my opinion.


There were some marital problems in her life as the article above mentions a possible divorce. Another thing that stood out with this case is the letter. What does it mean when someone sends a letter saying that she is going to a far-away city but then is never heard from again?

Before speculating on that, let's stick to known facts. There was a classified advertisement for this missing person that appeared in 2006.

This advertisement claims that she was last in the presence of Samual Ray Phillips (July 1st, 2006; Cincinnati Enquirer), who died in 2004 in a car accident. I think the proper spelling of this person's name was Samuel Ray Phillips, with the "e" in his first name instead of an "a." 

I found a gravemarker on Findagravel.com for a Fairfield man of this name who died in 2004.


By my research, Samual is spelled wrong in this classified ad. Should be Samuel.

Samuel Ray Phillips

Born: November 7th, 1928
Death: January 24th, 2004
Gravemarker suggests a marriage to "Rose M." born in 1934 (possible Rosemary Brown).
Ancestry: This individual is on Ancestry

There was a second piece of journalism on Phyllis Maue in February 2006. Deborah Dixon of The Journal News headlined "Police say missing woman may be tied to Fairfield man." In this article, Ray Phillips is mentioned. It is also stated that police were planning some digs to search for her body. Other important details from this piece of journalism:
  • Phyllis left an uncashed paycheque behind. Uncashed assets appear in quite a few missing persons cases. I think it suggests that the person, when last seen, did not plan to disappear voluntarily. If the MP did plan to disappear voluntarily, most would take their negotiables with them.
  • Her husband received a nude photo of her in the mail that suggested an extramarital affair with Ray Phillips;
  • Reportedly, Maue was going to end the affair on June 25th, 1982.


One interesting fact is that a handwriting expert looked at the letter from Phyllis Maue. He concluded that she did write the letter. However, the handwriting expert also stated that the letter writer was under stress as she wrote.

You have to wonder if an expert of this sort could discern a trembling hand from handwriting. Also, someone under duress might pause while writing -- and this could leave an ink blob. I think her handwriting would have to be compared to normal script. But, for sure, this is not an exact science but rather food for critical thought.

Has Phyllis Maue Been Found?

In my opinion, the totality of the scene suggests that a murder took place. The letter was used as a diversion. I think someone forced her to write it, believing that ostensibly placing her in New York City would explain what was going to be a prolonged...or permanent...absence.

This would help create a diversion and a length of time for the disappearance to be considered voluntary. The more time that passes, the more difficult it is for the authorities to solve the case.

Ronald and Theresa Yakimchuk -- Missing Since June 1973 on a Road Trip

Author: Shane Lambert
Original Time of Writing: January 21st, 2021
All articles are subject to editing after the original posting.


Missing person #1: Ronald Yakimchuk
Last-seen date: June 5th, 1973; might be June 1st, 1973
Last-seen location: Brandon, Manitoba
Last-contact: June 12th, 1973. A postcard from Dryden, Ontario (sent by wife)
Link to Government Source: Canada's Missing
Ethnicity/Race: Caucasian
Sex: Male
Age at time of disappearance: 27
Hair: Brown
Eye color: Brown
Height and weight at the time of disappearance: 6'0" and 150 pounds, which would look very lean
Cenotaph: Findagrave


Missing person #2: Theresa Yakimchuk
Alias: Terry Pettit (Terry is a derivative of Theresa, Pettit is likely the maiden name)
Last-seen date: June 5th, 1973; might be June 1st, 1973
Last-seen location: Brandon, Manitoba
Last-contact: A postcard from Dryden, Ontario (June 12th, 1973)
Link to Government Source: Canada's Missing
Ethnicity/Race: Caucasian
Sex: Female
Age at time of disappearance: 23
Hair: Blonde
Eye color: Blue
Height and weight at the time of disappearance: 5'4" and 121 pounds

Ronald and Theresa Yakimchuk were from Edmonton, Alberta. They traveled east in the spring of 1973 using a "faded red" Volkswagen Beetle "with an off-green hood and rear fender." This vehicle also had a three-meter-long and white kayak affixed to the top of it.

Mon, Jun 9, 1980 – 4 · Edmonton Journal (Edmonton, Alberta, Canada) · Newspapers.com

There is some inconsistency between the historical journalism that covered this case and modern government database information. The vehicle in question might be anywhere from 1956 to 1959 (plate: Alberta, CA3-262). The picture below is the last one taken of the missing couple and it shows their vehicle as well.



The missing people were traveling to Montreal to attend a wedding. However, they never made it to that wedding.

The date of the wedding that they were planning on attending was called "mid-June" in an article in the June 9th, 1980 edition of The Edmonton Journal. Another source says the exact date of the wedding was June 16th, 1973 (Nov 17 2007 Edmonton Journal). They sent a postcard on June 12th, 1973 from a town called Dryden, Ontario.

Search Area or Incident Location: Disappearance Event Focus, Dryden to Montreal


Presumptively, something happened to them between Dryden and Montreal between the dates June 12th and June 16th. In fact, the area between Dryden and Ottawa is more probable.

The couple visited someone known as "an associate" in Brandon, Manitoba. I believe that this visitation might be the last physical sighting of them.

Furthermore, Canada's Missing says they went missing on June 1st but some journalism on this matter says they left Edmonton on June 5th, 1973. If that is true and if they visited associates in Brandon, Manitoba, then you would have to think they were last seen on at least June 7th, 1973, as the drive from Edmonton to Brandon is not one that most drivers would complete in a day.

Complicating this case is the lack of clarity regarding the missing couple's travel plans. While they did want to attend a wedding, they "planned to travel indefinitely after that." A news piece on this missing couple from 2023 stated that they were planning to start a new life in the Maritimes.

The family did not start to worry about their well-being until a few months after they were last seen. Furthermore, the police didn't help with this case until seven months after they went missing, as per the source below.

Mon, Jun 9, 1980 – 4 · Edmonton Journal (Edmonton, Alberta, Canada) · Newspapers.com

Unredeemed Cash Draft Should Be Considered a Huge Clue as to Whereabouts


One important detail, in this case, has to do with a banking matter. Terry Pettit (ie. Theresa Yakimchuk) purchased a "cash draft" from her bank account in Edmonton and, from what I'm gleaning from the journalism, she planned to redeem it in Ottawa. However, this was not done.

For that reason, I would limit the focus area to in-between Dryden and Ottawa. They sent the postcard from Dryden so they were there. If they made it to Ottawa, it stands to reason that Theresa would have cashed the bank draft.

Monetary assets are rarely treated in a frivolous matter. In my opinion, when something like a cash draft, money order, paycheque, or personal check goes uncashed in a missing person's case, it should always be considered extremely relevant. For that reason, I do not think they made it to Ottawa.

I think a "cash draft" might be called a "money order" in more modern lingo. Back then, I think it would have been called a cashier's cheque or a bank draft. It's like a cash that cannot bounce because the funds for it are already guaranteed, much like a loaded VISA debit card in contemporary times.

Ottawa, as a potential destination, is important in this case. One early report having to do with this case said the missing people had friends there. These friends never met the couple that summer (Edmonton Journal Jan 22 1974).

Mon, Jun 9, 1980 – 4 · Edmonton Journal (Edmonton, Alberta, Canada) · Newspapers.com

Couple Considered Dead as of 1980


The opinion of family and police on this matter, in 1980, was that the Yakimchuks had somehow died.

Leads have not been numerous, but in 2007 it was reported that someone claimed to have seen them in July 1973. According to this person, she and her husband saw the Yakimchuks highway-side near Parry Sound, Ontario in what would have been late-July of 1973.

The witness described a Volkswagen Beetle, a man that looked like Ronald, a woman that looked like Theresa, a third man, and Alberta license plates.

This sighting did not make a lot of sense to me for a few reasons. I think something happened to them between June 12th and June 16th, 1973. So the late-July 1973 sighting does not make a lot of sense. Also, a route through Parry Sound would not be the most efficient one between Dryden and Ottawa. Lastly, a 34-year gap between the sighting and the reporting date leaves some questions about the person's memory. As per the description below, the kayak on the roof is missing, which simply suggests that it's a different vehicle and different people.

Sat, Nov 17, 2007 – 3 · Edmonton Journal (Edmonton, Alberta, Canada) · Newspapers.com

Note: in the article above, "CFB Shilo" would be a Canadian military base near Brandon, Manitoba.

Even with Alberta plates, the area around the Great Lakes in Ontario is popular enough for tourism that it would not be surprising to see plates from any part of Canada, especially during the summer months.

If the kayak had been on the vehicle, then that would have been a much more convincing sighting. I wouldn't discount this sighting, but it is not convincing to me. It's something that those who are interested in this case need to be familiar with. But my feeling is that something else needs to align with this alleged sighting before it can be taken too seriously.

Remember, the missing people did not make their wedding target in Montreal for June 16th. They sent no communications after the Dryden postcard. Furthermore, Theresa did not redeem her cash draft in Ottawa. I still think that a highway mishap befell this couple somewhere between Dryden and Ottawa.

Dryden Location Means They Had Plenty of Time to Get to Montreal


These were 20-somethings who seemed to be interested in growth via travel at a young point in their lives. They might have explored the back areas of Ontario -- not just the main tourist spots near the main highways. If they were in Dryden on June 12th, then they were close enough to Montreal that they had a few days of free time before the wedding.

That their vehicle has never been found is a major point in this case. However, I did read one article from 1980 that suggested that their vehicle had been found. I did not find a follow-up article to this.

Tue, Jun 17, 1980 – 54 · The Gazette (Montreal, Quebec, Canada) · Newspapers.com


Car Not Found, People Still Missing


There are lots of missing persons cases where the vehicle is found but the driver and passengers remain missing. It seems that finding a vehicle is a lot easier than finding the primary subjects of searches. In fact, "car found person missing" is one of the most common tags on this website.

That the Yakimchuks' vehicle has never been found could mean that the vehicle went missing with the passengers. This is something that has happened numerous times.

One case that this reminded me of is the missing-person case of Janet Farris. In 1992, she was driving from Vancouver Island to a wedding in Alberta. Like the Yakimchuks, she never made the wedding. She was never heard from again and nor was her car ever found -- until 201,9 when it was pulled out of a lake in the Revelstoke area.




Notable Cases of Missing Persons Found Submerged with Their Vehicles


NameDisappearance DateLast Known LocationCar DetailsDiscovery DateSubmersion Location
Janet FarrisAugust 1992Vancouver Island, BC, Canada1969 Plymouth BarracudaAugust 2018Griffin Lake, BC, Canada
David Hannah1983Bath, Ontario, CanadaUnspecified carMay 2023Lake Ontario, near Amherstview
William MoldtNovember 7, 1997Lantana, Florida, USAWhite 1994 Toyota CelicaAugust 2019Pond near housing development
Donna Graves & SonJanuary 18, 2013Ottawa, Ontario, CanadaDodge DartJanuary 20, 2013Ottawa River, Ottawa, Canada

Reported: CBC News
Larry Anderson2004Murray, Utah, USALeased car (make unspecified)February 2025Flaming Gorge Reservoir, Utah

Reported: CBS News
  • Janet Farris: Confirmed as a 1969 Plymouth Barracuda, per CBC reporting referenced in your blog.
  • David Hannah: Car details aren’t widely specified in public reports (e.g., Kingston-area news); it’s simply noted as "his car."
  • William Moldt: Identified as a white 1994 Toyota Celica in police and news accounts from 2019.
  • Donna Graves: Reported as a Dodge Dart in Ottawa police statements from 2013.
  • Larry Anderson: Described as a leased car in Utah news, with no make or model detailed in early 2025 reports.

Missing people in their vehicles are sometimes found in roadside bushes. But Ontario is well known for having thousands of lakes. It can be hard to picture a car going off of the highway and ending up in a deep part of a lake as you might picture the shallow depths stopping the car's momentum. However, cars can go off highways and submerge at significant enough depth to be hidden for decades.

One officer who worked on this case seemed to think that the car and the missing people may have entered Lake Superior -- at least, he acknowledged the possibility. I align my own hunches with his.

I would think Lake Superior and any other water not far off the main route between Dryden and Ottawa would be part of the search area. Unfortunately, the area is so immense that the manpower is not likely to be afforded to cover all the possible areas.

Sat, Nov 17, 2007 – 3 · Edmonton Journal (Edmonton, Alberta, Canada) · Newspapers.com

But make no mistake -- this is a case that Websleuths and amateur investigators can help with. There was a case in 2019 that was solved when a Google Earth user found a submerged car using that software. The car was located in a small body of water, not far from shore, and inside the car was a missing person who had been there for decades.

Many rivers might have submerged a car that was driven off of a bridge. However, if everyone who reads this took ten minutes to use Google Earth to search the shallow depths of lakes and rivers that come close to highways, then it might yield results in the long run. I don't know what color the car would be now, but maybe a kayak might still be affixed to the top -- maybe not. That's the direction I think this search should go in when it comes to amateur contributions.

If you are researching this case, then it may be fruitful to use "Ron Yakimchuk" or "Terry Pettit" as your keywords. Those are the names that turned up hits in the newspaper archives that I looked at.

Other details:
  • Their car was not in good condition
  • Lt. Col Sid Stephen was the last person to see them near Brandon, Manitoba
  • He warned them about dangerous stretches en route to Montreal
  • Someone found what appears to be a VW Beetle buried in their backyard; it will be interesting if leads develop (see the Websleuths forum)

Prediction: They Will Be Found


I don't think there's a police budget in Ontario big enough to search every highway-side body of water. But my prediction for this case is that they will be found by a random citizen or dedicated volunteer because these people aren't on the clock. Fishermen, swimmers/divers with new underwater technology, or magnet fishers are all the kinds of people who might find a submerged vehicle, whether while looking for it or accidentally.

Timeline of Ronald and Theresa Yakimchuk’s Disappearance


DateEvent
Early Spring 1973Ronald and Theresa plan a trip east from Edmonton, Alberta, in their VW Beetle.
June 1st, 1973Official disappearance date per Canada’s Missing (RCMP); contested by June 5th departure.
June 5th, 1973Depart Edmonton, per journalism.
June 5th–7th, 1973Last seen in Brandon, Manitoba, by Lt. Col. Sid Stephen; warned about dangerous routes.
June 12th, 1973Theresa sends postcard from Dryden, Ontario (last contact).
June 12th–16th, 1973Disappear between Dryden and Ottawa; miss Montreal wedding on June 16th.
June 16th, 1973Wedding date in Montreal they fail to attend.
Late July 1973Unverified sighting of a similar VW Beetle near Parry Sound, Ontario (no kayak).
Late 1973Family begins worrying after months of no contact.
January 1974Police investigation begins, seven months after disappearance.
1980Family and police presume couple dead; unconfirmed report suggests vehicle found.

Featured Post

Carbon Jane Doe - Funeral Home Theory

Author : Shane Lambert Original Time of Writing : August 23, 2025 All articles are subject to editing after the original posting. Could F...

Best of MPC (as selected by the site's author)